Copyright © 2009 Masterworks Inc. All rights reserved.
Revised: 02/12/11
 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Copyright © 2009 Masterworks Inc. All rights reserved.
Revised: 02/12/11
 

 

 

 

Copyright © 2009 Masterworks Inc. All rights reserved.
Revised: 02/12/11
 

 

 

Copyright © 2009 Masterworks Inc. All rights reserved.
Revised: 02/12/11
 

 

Copyright © 2009 Masterworks Inc. All rights reserved.
Revised: 02/12/11
 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

           

 

Design of Your New Home

a book on the design of new homes

Chapter 6  -    Now the House  -  continued

More on Framing

This section of the chapter will finish up on the topic of framing started previously in the 'Eggshell' section. Unfortunately significant information will be passed over since much of  the subject deals more on the Construction of a house than in the Design. As said in Chapter 1  this book can not do both and there are other sources available on construction, how to build and engineering. Click here for those. In addition it is recommended that you watch a house being built. Take one of the books along since this is an essential part of your education. Lastly, if what is presented here is confusing this recommendation should be considered essential.

 

Topics

What  Designers Need to Know - Types of Framing

Your Budget is Really Tight

Interior Structural Walls

Framing for Construction Drawings

  

 

 

 What Designers Need to Know About Framing                                                     

Framing is a crossroad for the home owner designer and the time to get tedious for the budding RT/RD (Residential Technician / Residential Designer).  Generally speaking a plan can be 'designed' and laid out without much regard to framing if some basic restrictions are recognized. Still framing must be engineered by someone. Determination of the components is crucial to the builder and to the success of your design. Someone must tell the builder how to frame or you must find a builder who will do the engineering themselves.  It goes back to Chapter 4.  Remember when we discussed whether you plan to get help or do construction drawings yourself?

 Let us break down, as in Chapter 4, the framing duties by the role you intend to play. 

    1. You will do Construction Documents yourself (you are probably the budding RD/RT).
    2. You would like to understand how framing works but you will find someone else to do the engineering.
    3. You only want to know enough to do your design.

 Number one and  two  require departing into engineering unless we can abbreviate the subject.  So let's do the Designer Knowledge Only, number 3 first.  For 1 and 2 we will do brief comments and refer  readers to the other books which can do the subject the justice it deserves.

Fundamentals

 Today's light wood construction combined with engineered wood products has made framing easier for the beginning Designer. Long span floor and roof trusses are capable of economically spanning large distances with little trouble. Long spans mean floor plans that, if you desire, are unencumbered, within the span allowances, by 'load bearing walls' and other structural components (columns and posts). There are several framing types and components that make up your 'menu' for residential  framing.  Basic knowledge of these and how they work combined with  some 'rules of thumb' should allow you to get started on your designs while your structural engineering experience grows.(1) (also see ebook for graphics)

     Solid  wood framing lumber (Stick Construction):

  •    Boards cut directly from soft wood trees to standard  industry sizes .

  • Standard Sizes: are 2" x 4"  and 2" x 6"s for walls: 2" x 8" through 2" x 12" for floors and roofs.

  • Floor Spans: conservative floor spans for living areas is 12 to 14 feet. (using 2x10s & 2 x 12s @ 16" on center (OC)). Spans for bedroom floors can be slightly more, say 16 feet.

  • Roof Spans: roof span limitations with 2x8s at 16" on center (oc). are: 20 to 28 ft depending on slope, snow and material weight. See below for trusses.

  • Spacing: spacing  for floor joists is usually 16"oc, maximum 24".

  • HVAC: ducts can not be cut through solid wood framing.

Wood Floor Trusses: graphic courtesy of Alpine Truss.

  • Each truss uses solid top and bottoms (cords) with open space between (webs). Diagonal members connect the cords.

  • Standard Sizes (depth): range in depth from 12" to 24".

  • Floor Spans: maximum conservative floor span  for living areas is 30 feet.

  • Spacing:  is either 19.5" or 24" on center (oc).

  • HVAC: ducts can pass through  trusses (the web is open).

Wood Roof Truss: graphic courtesy of Alpine Truss

  • Pre-shaped to roof and ceiling design with the same construction as a floor truss above.

  • Standard Sizes: none, a wide range of shapes and sizes are available per your job requirements.

  • Roof Spans: conservative maximum span for light snow regions and light roof materials = 50ft.

  • Spacing:  is usually 24" on center oc.

  • HVAC: ducts pass thru  freely.

   Engineered I Joists:

  • Similiar to the Floor Truss above but the web is solid and made of plywood. Can be used for floor or roofs (flat or sloped).

  • Standard Sizes: range in standard depth from 10" to 16".

  • Floor Spans: maximum conservative span  for living areas is 25 feet. 

  • Roof Spans: see manufactures literature.

  • Spacing:  is usually 16" or 19.5" oc.

  • HVAC: cutting for ducts is possible using the deeper joists.

   Engineered Beams & Headers: photo courtesy of Truline Truss

  • Made of either wood strands or chips pressed into rectangular shapes and /or laminated together for needed width. These replace solid wood framing when added strength and span is required.

  • Generally 2" increments both in height and width.

  • Floor Spans: see manufactures literature, significantly greater than solid wood framing.

  • Roof Spans: see manufactures literature, significantly greater than solid wood framing.

  • Spacing: As required.

  • HVAC: Can not be cut unless beam is oversized and hole is small (ie: elec. conduit).

Comments, Tips and Rules of Thumb

In addition to the fundamental restrictions above there are a number of items that once assimilated will allow the designer to go forward with intelligent designs.

Cost Related Items

  •  The cost differences between framing types are not so high as to require extensive cost discussion.  Unless the most economical house  is required don’t worry  too much about cost. Just know that if you can keep your room sizes below 16 feet in the narrow dimension you will save a little money in framing cost.  But for those wide open 'great rooms' some long span framing should not break the bank.

  • Remember in Chapter 2  rough carpentry was 16-18% of the cost of an entire standard house. Consider floor and roof framing to be (for easy numbers) half of that.  Of this remainder your increase due to framing choices is maybe  20 to 30% which then comes  out around 2% of the entire house cost!

  • TIP: In an economy house do not obsess too much about framing cost since costs differences between types is not huge and is often offset by numerous other factors.

Floor and Roof Truss

  • Roof Trusses can span up to 70 feet (see appendix) if your roof slope is 6/12 (height/span) or above. Although there are many factors involved in any truss design the truss manufacturer will do the actual engineering using their licensed engineers. You, the designer  only need to stay within a reasonable maximum span.

  • TIP:  steeper roofs allow longer roof truss spans. 

  • Floor trusses can span beyond 30 feet if you refer to the manufacturer's literature.

  • The issue with longer spans is 'bounce' and permanent 'deflection'. Bounce is just what it sounds like. When someone walks across a floor you will feel as though you are on a trampoline (obviously I am exaggerating).

  • Also due to a number of reasons the members in longer spans  can 'bow' to the middle (deflect). Depending on the extent of the bow it can be noticeable and bothersome. (we have all seen sagging floors). Although I have tried to take this and the bounce into account with my rules of thumb, it is prudent when approaching maximums to check these issues.

  • Both bowing and deflection can be solved simply by either shortening the span or stiffening the span somewhere in the middle third (plus or minus). You can use either a beam or a stiffening wall.   Both go below and perpendicular to the span. It is only necessary for the designer to  accommodate the intervention. The construction drawing (CD) person takes care of the rest in conjunction with the building codes (see the eBook diagrams).

  • Truss's are good for running air ducts, electricity and plumbing. The designer can assume dropped ceilings or lowering closet heights will not be necessary. These represent a cost savings which can offset the cost of trusses.

  • Trusses are 'old growth forest' friendly. Think of doing your floor out of solid 2x12s.  The tree required for a 2 x 12 must be  greater than 12" in diameter and to get more than one board significantly larger trees are needed.  A truss on the other had if made of 2 x 6's needs a tree only half the size.

  • Roof trusses are  usually more economical than ceiling rafters and roof joists.
  • TIP - So a roof truss can be used in both categories; economical and not so economical construction.

Solid Framing for Floors & Roofs

  • Rooms wider than the span rules of thumb  are common but require load bearing review by your CD (construction drawing) person. See the Walls section below  for more discussion.

  • You can not run air ducts through solid floor joists, only in the same direction.

 

  •  To run ducts perpendicular to joists you must have space between the ceiling and the bottom of the 'joist'. (Since light wood solid framing occurs every 24" or less, there is no room to raise a ceiling in between). Higher ceilings will require a special truss shape, higher bearing wall and joist height, or Post and Beam  framing. There is also the possibility of:

  1. Lowering the height inside a closet, bathroom, or hall.

  2. Provide chases around the perimeter of rooms and above cabinets. (not common, too much trouble).

  • If raised joists are used, a common solution is to do a 10 or 11 foot floor to floor height. Lower the ceiling to 8 feet and use the space between for your ducts, plumbing and electric runs. The smart designer will organize the utilities so that some major rooms can have a 9 or 10 foot high ceiling.

  • A minor advantage of 'stick' floors is the ability to cantilever a floor beyond the wall or beam supporting it.  The building codes once allowed a very meager 1 foot but with an architect's or engineer's help getting out to 4 feet or more is doable. Sheltered porches, balconies or sunrooms might be done like this although engineers don’t like it.

  • A major advantage of stick ceilings/roofs construction is allowing your main living rooms to 'soar' in height. There are only a few limitations to get in your imaginations way. Sloping cathedral ceilings or 2 story high rooms all are easy with sticks. Where with roof truss your pitch is more limited and requires a special truss.

  • Structural support at the limit of your span is discussed under Walls.

Your Budget Is Really Tight                                                                                  

We discussed in the section "the 2x4 Eggshell---" solid light wood construction is generally the most economical of all framing solutions . The same statement can be said of solid light wood floor framing but not necessarily about it's use in roofs. So, cost wise it is a mixed bag, (summarized below). The question the designer must ask is do I want to accept the limitations of solid lumber floor framing for the cost advantages?  We listed  the basic limitations above. If you looked at them carefully you will see compared to the other floor/roof framing large differences. (Keep in mind those are conservative general numbers to give the Designer a working framework).  To summarize  differences find the following:

Solid Framing vs Engineered Wood

  • Walls - less cost, solid 2 x 4" studs allow only a 2 story high house.

  • Floors -Solid joists are less cost, but have significant span reductions and mechanical electric restrictions. (see footnote1).

  • Roofs - Solid wood rafters usually cost more than light truss, and have significant span limits.

Structural Walls                                                                                                                         

To say the obvious there are (4) types of full height walls:

  • Exterior Load Bearing --  If your roof is to be sloped, the walls at the bottom of the slope are load bearing. Openings in this wall are subject to either limits or engineering. See the section on Shell Parts/Windows for more.

  • Exterior non Load Bearing --  Walls not carrying sloped roof loads carry only wind loads. The limitations are less.

  • Interior Load Bearing --  These carry either roof or floor loads at the end of the structural spans discussed previously.

  • Interior non Load Bearing (partitions)--  Carry no loads, have fewer limits unless used as a stiffener for bounce and deflection.

 Interior Load Bearing Walls

 These are your items of concern inside your house.  You have devised a great floor plan and whole bunch of walls separate your rooms.  Which are load bearing and subject to limitation and which are not?  What are the limitations?  All essential questions.

 Here is it as simply put:

  • Overlay on each floor of your plan a sheet of drawing tissue.
  • Diagrammatically sketch the joists or truss until they run their maximum spans  or until you have a wall that occurs below. If a wall is below then it is Load Bearing.
  • If there is no wall below  you must put one in or have a beam engineered with end supports (posts or another wall).
  • Play with the direction of your spans until you find the best solution.
  • For an engineered beam go to the section "Framing for Construction Drawings".
  • For a Load Bearing Wall see below.

Openings in Load Bearing Walls

 If your bearing wall falls on the lowest floor your job as the designers is done except for alerting the RT / construction drawer to its presence. This person will take the loads 'to gound' on their foundation or framing plan. If your wall falls lets say a floor above the lowest one then you must get the loads down to the lowest floor in a manner that works for your hard earned floor plan as well as satisfying  the engineering. There are several solutions:

  • Work with the CD person to devise transferring loads by way of a 'flush framing' solution. (see the Framing for Construction Drawings section coming up).
  • Run a wall and puncture it with openings.
  • Run screaming out of the room and quit.

 If a wall that has one or more openings in it works with your design this is probably the simplest way to go. There are though, as with everything, limitations as follows: 

  • Openings 8 feet or less in width can be used without much concern. The header can be made up of 2x10s or less. Openings greater than 8 feet need engineering attention.
  • The designer's concern is making sure that the increase in loads created by the opening also 'goes to ground' as discussed above and that any support is accounted for in the floor plan below them.  (If that did not make sense then keep in mind the opening you made transfers the load to the opening's sides and creates a 'concentrated load' or a 'point load' vs. an evenly 'distributed load'. The point load must be engineered and carried down. You the designer must account for this).
 

So there you designers have it. You can have all the clear space you want within these limits. And you can place walls where ever you wish without regard to supporting anything (again within these limits). Also, if the spans above are too restrictive an engineer, architect or experienced RD/RT (Residential Designer) can find you some more.

 

 Framing for Construction Drawings                                                                                      

Once you get the hang of what I have been saying in a very general manner the work will not seem bad. In the mean time unless you have an engineering background (or other technical fields) brace yourself.  To engineer framing plans there are steps that must be gone through and knowledge to be digested. Unfortunately as I said  these can not occur in this book.  (Also forgive me since I am about to do what will seem like a cop out). Instead this is what you must do:

  •  Study any number of books on house construction and framing. There  are several in our bookstore as well as the JLC Field GuideJLC Field Guide to Residential Construction. .                                                                                          

  • From these books and from your local Building Code acquire load and span tables with their associated technical adjuncts. (see the eBook Appendix for  an example).

  • Manufacturer's literature is an invaluable resource. Trusses and engineered wood products are well represented on the web and when you dig into them your framing questions should be cleared up. Your first framing plan then is only steps away.
  • For roof truss basics go to  Alpine Truss
  • For floor truss and engineered joists (I Joists) refer to trulinetruss.com  
  • For solid 2x lumber see  Southernpine spantables

Samples from the above links are in this book's appendix and provide an idea of what you are looking for.  Start with a book on wood framing. It is imperative that the person doing construction documents understand this subject. Here are where the bigger mistakes can occur during construction and here is where significant liability lurks.  Do not rely only on the builder to catch mistakes. Remember they are often busy building other houses as well. Imagine the problems if the experienced boss is off site and his less experienced helper misses an error YOU made.  It gets built and one of two things may happen:

  • It has to be rebuilt at considerable extra expense or, you never know,

  • a structural failure might occur. 

 If you are doing framing for the first time, the bottom line is study, study, study and then have a PE review your final work.  And remember you only have to get through this once. After that it will be like riding a bike.

                                                                                                                                                           

for the remainder of this chapters topics as well  graphics  purchase this book.  

purchase this book .

to the top of the Chapter

read more

                                                                                                

 

                                                                                                                              

 


(1) It is important for the designer to understand basic structural concepts and properties involved in  determining framing sizes and uses. The building codes and manufactures technical material, with study, can bring you up to speed. In the mean time using  the 'rules of thumb' can be done if and only if an engineer reviews the framing plans or an experienced RT does the construction drawings. Also to repeat again: check with your building department.  Drawings and engineering may require the stamp of an Architect or Engineer.

(2).Floors - "less cost, but significant span reductions". This statement is not always true and requires careful analysis. For example is there extra cost resulting from dropped ceilings for utilities.  Are there more footings and floor beams due to shorter spans? Are there load bearing walls or beams which could be avoided if spans were longer? It is not impossible for solid wood floor framing to be more expensive than longer span I Joists.